Just read the Classic Picks thread. All the talk of the missing pieces of the puzzle with SRR etc.. got me thinking about the greats that no one will ever get to see properly. I presume most posters on here read about the sport and its history and know all the great names from pre-movie reel days. So, in a desert islands discs style scenario, if you could magically order the DVD boxset of any five pre-modern (every fight taped, someone who little footage exists of etc.. you get the picture) era who would they be? Lets not go back too far with this to the days of Jem Mace and co. For me 1) Jack Dempsey (Nonpariel) 2) John L Sullivan 3) Joe Gans 4) Johnny Kilbane 5) Harry Greb
sam langford. the uncrowned champ 150 KO's over 300 fights dempsey refused to give a over 40 year old blind langford a shot and he fought the best while jack johnson held the title and wouldn't fight him
Fitz - Considering he won the HW title, just how good a middleweight was he in his prime? Greb - to try and gauge how he would have done aganst the likes of Monzon, Hagler, Hopkins Jimmy Wilde - to try get an opinion of how he would have fared in the modern era at Lt Fly (a weight he could have made with ease) against the Latin and Asian fighters that have been around since WWII, the type of matches that were often too hard to arrange before commercial aircraft were commonplace. Charey Burley - is his reputation amongst the hardcore historians deserved or just a backlash against the popular vote of Ray Robinson as being the best around that weight at the time? Ray Robinsons Welterweight career.
Benny Lynch, of course. He got married within half an hour of where I live. I hate to sound arrogant, but I bet most boxing fans here dont know their boxing history. Thats why I come over like a ***** when I argue here sometimes, cos I suppose at the end of the day I expect people to be on my level in a boxing argument, when in reality they aint got a prayer. Thankyou, & goodnight.
In both Dempseys and Johnsons defense there was no real call for Dempsey to defend against a blind 40 year old or for an all black heavyweight title fight involving Johnson-Langford (Johnson had beaten Langford before he won the title). I think its fair to say that while Langford deserved a rematch with Johnson for the title, even Dempseys harshest critics wouldn't accuse him of ducking Langford after he'd won the title. Harry Wills (who had a very good record against the older Langford) is a far bigger omision on Dempseys record but white America wasn't keen on black fighters challenging for the heavyweight title so soon after the nightmare of Jack Johnson. I beleive Dempsey signed to fight Wills but the promotion was cancelled for economic and racial reasons, so a fight against a 40 year old Langford (who Wills had fought and beaten pretty regulary prior to that time) would'nt have had a hope in hell of getting off the ground.
Duran for his all out fighting style Willie Pep & Nicolino Locche to see their finesse Joe Louis for his one punch knock outs Ali for his Charisma John L Sullivan for the old days fighting
theres footage of every mentioned here but Greb so hes my pick although i would have loved to see Pep live in his prime
well what I was going for was being able to see their entire career. I know you can get footage of a lot of the boxers mentioned but most of it is bitty and unsubstantial. I was talking about getting a really good look at a load of fights. I guess anyone who finished their career before the early to mid 1940's would be hard to judge due to lack of a lot of film. People like Duran are easily accessible. I own a boxset of his fights
1)Greb - his record is amazing. I'd love to see him fight. 2)Burley - there's some footage out there but not enough! 3) WW version of Robinson - there's no footage of him at WW I think. 4) Fitz - 3 weight world champ from MW to HW. How good was he at MW? 5) WIlde - probably the greatest British fighter of all time but there's not enough footage. edit: **** these are the same as Gaz's atsch