Here's some more of what the papers say. The San Francisco Call Headline: Dissipation and Jeffries down Jackson "It was a well known fact that Jackson was a physical and financial wreck when he arrived in this city from England...the result of his love for strong liquor." The paper goes on to criticise the match and the athletic club for making it, putting Jackson's life at risk in doing so. It also publishes the doctor's remarks that he was passed fit to fight and looked good. Arizona Republican Headline: There was only a trace of the old-time cleverness which had won him battles in opposite corners of the globe. LA HERALD Headline: Peter is a sure enough has-been. He was done.
What news papers say after an older fighter losses often contradicts what they say before. Much depends if they win. I have posted primary stuff here leading up the fight, and none of the doom and gloom was there.
Right. Because they've seen him fight. Literally any old alcoholic can get knocked into "good shape" by a team with enough time. But fighting shape was clearly beyond Jackson's reach.