Boxrec new rankings rates Mayweather #1 P4P All-time, Pacman #4.

I don't understand their scoring system whatsoever on how they rank ATG fighters. Based off lengthy resumes and overall competition it would seem like Harry Greb should be the #1 guy followed by guys like Pep than Armstrong.

I think Floyd's a top 20 guy but I don't see him anywhere near the top 10 at all. A strong case can be made for somewhere in the 13-17 range though.

The other "active" or recently retired guys are way too high as well. Only guy that has an argument as another top 20 guy is Manny Pacman.

 

The worst list I've seen.

 

I love boxing but I don't sit around making up p4p lists, unless you are getting paid for it you should have better things to do with your time. But if I did Floyd would certainly be nowhere near the top.

 

Great list.:yep

 

All time? atsch

 

:thumbsup

 

Wtf is Klitscko doing on there?

And Nelson?

 

Nonsense!!

 

Floyd and Manny are outside top 20. The list must be purely algorithmic, at least I hope it is or it was made by someone who has limited history of boxing.

 

Yeah terrible list. Duran should be much higher (even Floyd ranked him very high) Hopkins over Ali? Wtf. Wladimir is up that high too? Idk just so much wrong with it