You'd be right if you said "Super" Zab Judah is the most underrated welterweight out there today :good
I feel exactly the opposite, Williams has a better chance at Margarito. Clottey can't fight 12 full rounds in a Margarito fight. He'll get frustrated again in a losing effort.
Id favor Clottey over Margarito based on that fact that Clottey was more impressive in the rounds that he won than was Margarito in their first fight. Clottey's shell like guard was pretty impenetrable in the rounds he won and he was also able to land his left hook at will. Marg only looked good when Clottey stopped throwing punches and reteated to the ropes. I'm definitely one who believes that Clottey would have won if it wasn't for the sustained hand injury. And even with the injury I still scored the fight 6 rds a piece.
Clottey is more skilled and has just as much heart and power than Margarito ... the stamina is an issue that is questionable but I haven't seen Clottey fade like most have said. And if you got a guy thats willing to bang with Margarito - who knows how his stamina will hold up. Clottey hits well to the body as well, which will slow Margarito down.
Margarito was a late starter back then and will focus on the body. Clottey always fades late any ways.