Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

BTW TFFP you should get the thread title edited. The use of the word "dodgy" is a little misleading, "controversial" would be better.........

 

Hmm. I'm not doing anything, so I'll do this now. I've never actually seen this fight and by the sounds of it I should keep it that way but....meh.

 

Ill get around to scoring it sometime, I use to write all my scores down from fights on a shitty notepad which I threw away about 2 days ago, gutted now that could of got me out of scoring it again!

 

I had it to Collazo by two rounds.









NB: TFFP, since this is the Brit forum does this involve fights in which one or more of the opponents was actually British OR can we suggest other dodgy fights. In addition should we abstain from suggesting such obvious robberies as Santa Cruz v Casamayor and Zarate v Pintor, and concentrate on fights were there might be a more even split in opinion, like Hopkins v Taylor I and II, Marquez v Pacquiao I and II etc.

 

Its not a real stinker, just not a ******* either.

 

Great Idea, Ill follow suit now!!!

 

Christ I am halfway through and it is pretty bad, considering it is almost 1am right now.

 

oh gutted

Holyfield Qawi 1 and 2 are good i watched them 2 weeks ago with afew Don Curry early fights and Holyfield vs Dokes was a good night

everyone knows Santa Cruz won that its not controversial

if you do pac vs JMM 1 and 2 and Hopkins vs taylor 1 and 2 i have scorecards of them

 

Yes, but it deffo falls into the controversial bracket since the judges scoring was so, well, controversial:hey

And we are discussing controversial fights here.

 

suppose so them judges were as bent as the cast of Big brother

i think the next one has to be Hagler vs leonard

or Chris John vs JMM that is a very very controversial fight and the commentry is in Indonesian and absoulouttly hilarious

 

Now that Sir, is an excellent suggestion!!:good

 

What did you score them, off memory I gave 1st to pac by about 4 points, second to JMM by 1

 

abit obvious though

so Gaz How do you like it


right lads im away to watch Winky vs Quarty

speaking of Quarty

controversial Quarty fights are

Forrest
De la Hoya
Vargas

 

what off the top of my head it was JMM by 1 point the first time and 2 the second time

the first one i felt was easier to score as well