Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

Cheers.

 

Trinidad was a pretty easy fight to score!

 

Quartey would be my choice. Although if there is any doubt who wins round 12, my head may explode. :twisted:

 

:dealvery contoversial.
The others are good though and as long as this thread keeps on I'm sure they'll all be covered at some point

 

Who was your winner?I'm assuming Trinidad

 

The commentary for Oscar-Trinidad was quite one sided over the last few rounds IIRC?

 

I think he mean the rounds were easy to score unlike the last fight

 

I scored it for De La Hoya..... 116-112 I think.

Surely only Eugenia Williams could score that for Trinidad objectively - I know the Las Vegas judges love aggression but when one guy sweeps the frst half of the fight pretty much, the other has to win every other round and stick him on his ass to make sure. Trinidad didn't do that and should have lost.

It wasn't quite as bad as Lewis vs Holyfield I, probably on a par with Lewis vs Holyfield II had Evander been given the nod.

 

I thought the first round was 10-10 round.All 3 gave the second round to Trinidad.I have a bigger problem with those who give the first to Trinidad than those who give him the 2nd-neither man did anything in the 1st.Add to that Oscar threw away the last 4 and you have yourself a close fight

 

I will have to watch it again and post my card....

Think I gave Oscar all the first 8 and Trinidad the last 4.

 

oscar-quartey would be a good one.im also again suggesting tapia-ayala1