BRIT FORUM SCORES CONTROVERSIAL FIGHTS CLASSIC TRILOGY: Morales - Barrera II

Chacon-Edwards

10- 9
10- 9
8 - 10
9 - 10
10- 9
9 - 10
9 - 10
9 - 10
10- 9
10- 9
10- 9
10- 8

114-112 Bobby Chacon

What a remarkable war, its hard to find many fights that produce 'WOW' moment pretty much every round but this fight certainly does that. Such a tight close fight, either man would have been deserving of the win. Chacons face was an absolute mess by the end, brutal stuff.

Easily best choice of the series so far (including TFFPs old one) :good I would be keen on Froch-Kessler, am in need of rescoring it although I don't feel its controversial myself, close but clear Kessler win when I saw it live, maybe watching it again will change my mind! Pac-JMM II will never get boring despite how many times its viewd.

Tapia-Ayala I is a must :yep I love that fight.

 

Froch-Kessler is on Megavideo if I can post that?

 

Kessler-Froch is already up :good

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oxh7j7IeH1w[/ame]

Tapia-Ayala I

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gfsD5uGVBzs[/ame]

 

Haha, I edited it about 30 seconds after I posted it, not quick enough obviously :tong

 

[ dm ] insert video url [ /dm ] - no spaces though. Think it's something like that.

Anyway, how long before we move to another fight cos I still need to score Boza/Chacon II?

 

Not that many scorers yet for this one...:think

 

Strange.

Its the best of the lot so far, IMO.

 

Lets keep it at the top of the pile then

 

Ashamed to say I'd not seen this fight before - but here we go...

10-9 C
10-8 C
8-10 BE
9-10 BE
9-10 BE
10-10
9-10 BE
9-10 BE
10-9 C
10-9 C
9-10 BE
10-8 C

114-114

This was a horrid fight to score though. If it was simply on the overall dominance, then Boze-Edwards would have won, but it's a round by round thing, so Chacon's perseverance kept him in it.

Really, for me there were three rounds which effect the scoring most, the others were fairly clear. The first, the second and the sixth. In the first, I felt Boze-Edwards was winning the round in dominant fashion - not enough for a 10-8, but a clear 10-9. The knockdown made it a 10-9 for Chacon because he technically won the round, but it was a flash knockdown. If I'd given this 10-8 to Chacon, then II'd have had him winning by 115-113, same as Duane Ford.

The second... well, Boze-Edwards again was dominant, but the knockdown was so emphatic that it had to be a 10-8 for Chacon.

The sixth was a very tight round - and I felt Chacon's better shots were equal to Boze-Edwards volume of punches. But there's not much in this one, so I went for a draw. Could easily argue for a Boze-Edwards round though.

 

Rnd 1 10-9 Chacon
Rnd 2 10-8 Chacon
Rnd 3 10-8 Boza-Edwards
Rnd 4 10-9 Boza-Edwards
Rnd 5 10-9 Boza Edwards
Rnd 6 10-9 Boza-Edwards
Rnd 7 10-9 Boza-Edwards
Rnd 8 10-9 Boza-Edwards
Rnd 9 10-9 Chacon
Rnd 10 10-9 Chacon
Rnd 11 10-9 Chacon
Rnd 12 10-8 Chacon

113-112 Chacon

Great choice lads, cheers for that :good