British P4P List - Courtesy of the BBC

The Asikainen win was better than anything Brook has, although he's looked lethargic ever since.

Going nowhere, is Macklin, he just isn't very good. The kind of opponents Felix Sturm uses as 'defences'.

Get Macklin Vs Koji Sato on FFS, the only fight anyone wants to see at 160 :deal

 

Keiji Sato vs Paup Snith... the only fight anyone wants to see at 160 :deal

 

Someone on here posted a while back that they reckon Macklin is done, can't remember who it was.

He certainly seems to have lost a step from the Moore fight, which I suppose is understandable..... poor lad got absolutely creamed.

 

Froch should definitely be number one at the moment. Khan number two and then Haye a distant third. If Haye beats the K-brothers though that gets him right to the top spot, undisputed cruiserweight and then undisputed heavyweight champion, it would be undeniable.

 

Its good to see thpecial Kell getting a bit of praise for once.

Number 4 is a bit strong though, plenty of other guys with better wins on their CVs.

Brook should be 7th(ish) & ahead of DeGale, Cleverly & Murray imo.

 

that made me 'lol', well done sir

 

Ahead of Cleverly? :huh

 

1.Haye
2.Froch
3.Khan
4.Cleverly
5.Macklin/Burns

 

Ben Dirs is probably still doing it - i get the impression he's just a casual fan, so not surprised by these rankings to be honest.

but this whole thing is a joke until it is fixed whether p4p is about talent or record.
if its for talent, khan number 1 for me. for record, im tempted to say froch but are wins over pascal, taylor, dirrell (dodgy win), and abraham enough? probably yes.
if titles/prestige are included then prob haye just for being lineal and 2 weight champ - possibly more of a claim than froch's wins which can be picked apart.

 

I didn't include branning due to his inactive status. He would defo make an ATg list.

Phil Mitchell has a bloated record, and recently has taken to swapping punches with women, so he is omitted.

Gary from corrie has got form, and is on the fringes.

Part of me want to include the fella from holkyoakz, but if I'm being honest, I'm keeping him out due to vindictive reasons. He's a ****. Only eastenders can do back from the dead storylinez!

 

How the **** in Any world can brook be ahead of cleverly?
People in parallel universes are laughing their asses off at that!

 

The BBC rankings are so bad, even box Rec are better

 

The top 4 is spot on in my opinion.

Where is Rhodes, Gavin, Groves or DeGale though?

 

Cleverly hasnt done a great deal more or looked better doing it & is quite clearly Welsh.

If he beats Brahmer I will reluctantly put him above Kell but I dont think he will.