British P4P Top 15...

Lockett gets quite high solely on the basis of performances against Lee Blundell and Kai Kauramaki?

 

The Ryan Rhodes win.

 

Think Locketts win over Rhodes was over 18 months ago - July 2006?

 

How far do you reckon Rhodes will go, now he is boxing at his proper weight?

 

As Elle says, outside the timeframe. Though if my maths is right, there is another win against Ayitey Powers which just scrapes in.

Tbh using an 18 month timeframe for P4P ratings is just adding an additional layer of arbitraryness to what is already a subjective exercise.

 

1. Super Joe
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Woods
5. Witter
6. Macca
7. Arthur
8. Froch
9. Khan
10. Mitchell
11. Lockett
12. Rees
13. Moore
14. Barnes
15. Hide.....

 

This would be Mick Hennessy's list

1. Junior Witter
2. Carl Froch
3. Jon Thaxton
4. John Murray
5. Adnan Amar
6. Lenny Daws
7. Spartacus
8. John O'Donnell
9. Darren Barker
10. Esham Pickering

98. David Haye
99. Joe Calzaghe
100. Ricky Hatton

 

1. Joe Calzaghe
2. David Haye
3. Ricky Hatton
4. Carl Froch
5. Junior Witter
6. Clinton Woods
7. Enzo Maccarinelli
8. Alex Arthur
9. Amir Khan
10. Kevin Mitchell
11. Matt Skelton
12. Rendall Munroe
12. Jamie Moore
13. Gavin Rees
14. Nicky Cook
15. Wayne Elcock


suprised none of you have included Skelton

 

Lol

 

Calzaghe should be 1

 

Truth, and for the record p4p he would beat Floyd.

JC World P4P No1....:yikes

 

Lynes way too high

 

I don't know how anyone could have Haye above Hatton!

 

I may put him higher if he beats Branco on Friday!

Anyway talk about picking on me - I'm not the only one who has him in their Top 10.

Lets see your Top 15 then....

 

I'll post it later. I won't go by the 18 months thing. I don't follow the game closely enough to do that.