British P4P Top 50

In instead of Broadhurst that guy has fought no-one

 

its a good list but i think rogan is way to high up i personally wouldnt have him above mitchell and khan he has only had 12 professional fights

 

Might have only fought 12 fights but he has beat the best in britain

 

fair enough but when making a list like that i would compare boxers actual boxing skills and for that reason he doesnt deserve to be that high imo

 

True but boxing skills isn't all you need in boxing. You can have a good bit of skill and no heart (Audley) or a good bit of skill and no chin. P4P lists are always disputed because we look at different things in fighters. I can see why you wouldnt rate Rogie that high :good

 

Good list Rob, I'd have a few different but on the whole very good:good
Don't know about a top 50 but my top 30 would look something like this:

1) Ricky Hatton
2) David Haye
3) Carl Froch
4) Clinton Woods
5) Enzo Maccarinelli
6) Nicky Cook
7) Jamie Moore
8) Junior Witter
9) Ian Napa
10) Ryan Rhodes

11) Alex Arthur
12) Rendall Munroe
13) Kevin Mitchell
14) Martin Rogan
15) Paul McCloskey
16) Amir Khan
17) Darren Barker
18) Matt Skelton
19) John Murray
20) Michael Jennings

21) Bradley Pryce
22) Herbie Hide
23) Wayne Elcock
24) Jon Thaxton
25) Brian Magee
26) Paul Appleby
27) Kell Brook
28) Dean Francis
29) Martin Lindsay
30) Craig Watson

Khan Beating Barrera would propel him right into the top ten and a win for Nicky Cook into the top five. Brook needs some decent opponent's to be top 20 and theres some great domestic match ups coming up with Price/Hall, Elcock/Macklin and Lindsay/Appleby which would have some bearing on a top 20.

 

yea i agree with you there mate. i may not rate his boxing skills highly but you cant doubt the man has heart. hes a breath of fresh air and im glad hes about

 

McCloskey is well too low. How is Paul Appleby and Nathan Cleverly above him?

He's beaten Lynes, Bazan and Tontchev easily.

 

I would have McCloskey 20 to 25

 

Yeah.

Who has Nathan Cleverly beaten? A few Afro bums and Johnny Vegas?

 

Would you put Cleverly above Francis :huh

I think i would after Francis last fight

 

I really don't know what to say to some of those placings.

 

delete

 

great list rob, fair play