Broner officially cracks P4P. Ahead of Froch!

froch undoubtedly belongs ahead of broner.

 

Yeah, some ridiculous **** being said on this thread, for a nice change

 

He should be there, sould be way ahead of alverez but not froch no way should he be ahead of Carl

 

seriously. we're talking about a 34 year old seasoned, atg super middleweight who, next to maybe miguel cotto has consistently fought the toughest men in his weight range for years, versus a guy who just dominated his first near-elite opponent. there's no comparison just yet as far as i'm concerned.

 

When the **** did Sports Illustrated become the ''official'' subjective p4p list creators?

 

Since it has american fighters ahead of proven british warriors.

Seems legit.

 

Not a bad list although I feel Salido should be ranked higher for his win over undefeated Lopez and Garcia higher for his win over Khan.

I don't think I would have Bradley so high as I felt he was beat clearly by Pacquaio but could see him ranked 10 or just over for his wins over Alexander, Peterson, Holt, Witter , Campbell and Abregu.

 

My top 20 would probably have all the same guys, with the exception of Chocolatito instead of Canelo. Wouldn't be in the same order mind you but it's not a bad list. I'd push Gamboa out to 11 and move Froch in to 9 and would have Viloria and Cotto switch places. I'd take out Canelo, move Salido into 19 and stick Gonzalez in at 20. Would also have Pac at 3 behind PBF and Ward and Donaire above Wlad and Sergio.

Mayweather
Ward
Pacquiao
Marquez
Donaire
Martinez
Wlad
Bradley
Froch
Mares

Gamboa
Viloria
Vitali
Cotto
Broner
Moreno
Garcia
Dawson
Salido
Gonzalez

 

I wonder where these clowns would have put Bute p4p had he beat Froch ?


This is hilarious ,outside of this fight with Demarco what has Broner really done to be ranked above Froch a 3 time world champ ? Losses happen when you face the best ! Undefeated records are overhyped !

This knee jerk reaction is hilarious !

 

Sports Illustrated P4P means **** all.

 

So 1 solid win gets you close top 10 p4p.

Applying this ****** logic Brook could move close top 10 if he defeats Alexander ? eh no

 

No way Broner should be ranked ahead of Froch. I have Froch in the top 15 and Broner is in the top 20.

 

If Froch was American they would have him top 10 on that list.

But seeing as he's not wins agaoinst Pascal, Taylor. Dirrel, Abraham, Johnson and Bute don't seem to count for much.

 

you hoe ss poster!!! you didn't even read my list! I have Froch ranked higher than Broner. It's completely unbiased list! I rate Ward a #2 and I can't stand the muther****er. Mares top 10- can't stand him either! Viloria top 15 aheqad of Broner.....come on son use your comprehension skills next time. oh im soweee should Amir Khan be in there? **** off. I have favorites but don't overrate them if I did Sergio, Broner and Gamboa would all be much higher.