Brook vs Pacman at 147

Kell struggled with Porter, who is a poor mans Manny.

Manny still has enough left to eek out a UD, IMO.

Can Kell even make/or will he even go back to 147 now?

 

Kell has tweeted saying he would go down to 147 to box Manny and Eddie has retweeted it. I think Brook would come down to 147 for Khan, Manny, Floyd and the winner of Thurman v Garcia.

I don't think he'd beat Manny but he'd have a good puncher's chance. If Marquez can one punch KO Pac then Kell certainly can too.

 

Brook would stop Manny in brutal fashion.

 

Can't see manny fighting in U.K. And think brook too big make 147 and if did would be huge on fight night Manny also no this isn't stupid if he has fought larger guys usually are severe weight drained (de la Hoya margarito ) and usually Past best most would say kell at his prime whilst manny in decline.
If we're to go ahead tho manny on points wide or brook ko

TBH would love see brook vs Bradley then winner vs Garcia Thurman

 

I think Manny would beat him clearly

 

This isn't even a fight at this point... Brook takes him out in brutal fashion

Pac won clearly yesterday against an average champion in Vargas...but he was caught with some regularity by the straight right...That punch happens to be one of Brook's best, and besides the fact that Manny is slowing down in terms of defence, the power and size difference would just be too much. Brook knows this and that is why he wants the fight, Pac knows this and that is why the fight won't happen

 

Itd only happen if brook went over there, no way pac comes to uk.
And the mand vs spence would also have to be put aside.
Also i seriously doubt kell does 147 anymore he struggled before ggg and the extra bulk he acquired could be the straw to break the camels back.
But putting all the above aside and in theory now is the best chance kell would have to beat pac but imo pac still has enough to beat kell

 

pac as been done for a couple of years now

brook tko imo

eddie should try to make it but he wont

 

Manny hasn't got the power to keep Brook at bay, he's not stopped anyone since 2009. Eventually Kell would get to him and probably stop him late. Too big, too strong...

 

Even this older version of Pac would have far to much for Brook

 

Brook couldn't ever beat Porter convincingly! Pacquiao would comfortably UD Brook

 

What evidence have we seen that brook carry's serious power to trouble Manny?

 

PAC man for me. Ones brook mentioned he would only beat Garcia and Khan. Thurman 50/50.

 

I reckon manny still beats brook