Brook vs

I think Khan has the brain of a child.

 

i think brook would do a much better job on peterson than khan, be a terrific fight in fact and one i wouldnt mind happening one day, but still, brook on points.

Judah, I think brook would stop him in 6 to 10 rounds, still beat him.


Maidana would be the toughest fight for brook out of the four, tough to call, brook would win on points but his chin would be tested and maidana on his toes for the duration. exciting fight that will probably one day happen.

Mccloskey will probably not happen with both been at matchroom but brook wins this easily and should only really happen to sell out a big arena in either belfast or sheffield.

brook destroys paulie, no blueprint!
But yeah brook does 4 or 5 out of 5 here.

khan has the brains of a small child too.

 

BROOK VS PETERSON = ATM - Probably give Peterson the nod, purely as i havent seen Brook in with any legit world level fighters, whereas Peterson has done well to beat Khan and also get off the deck 3 times to salvage a draw vs Ortiz. Peterson UD.

BROOK VS MAIDANA = Think Brook UD's him, Maidana is too crude and struggled with an over the hill Morales. Maidana might get home with about 2-3 big shots, but if Brook can take the shots then he boxes the ears off him.

BROOK VS McCLOSKEY = Bleeeeuuggghh, horrible fight. McCloskey is terrible. Brook UD.

BROOK VS MALIGNAGGI = Brook TKO9. Never rated Malignaggi.

BROOK VS JUDAH = Brook UD, Judah is on the slide and always gasses late on. Aside from the southpaw defensive counterpunching problem, i see Brook overcoming that and winning about 9-3, something like that.

 

Peterson and Judah would give him something to think about , absolutely no doubt about that , Judah would be good while it lasted while Peterson has the better fundamentals and ama experience , i still feel he'd beat both (Judah being a little past his best) and Peterson being a tad too small in a pro contest

McCloskey and Maidana - Brook would hammer both :deal

 

so everyone reckons brook does well apart from the one who his anti anything to do with sky!

 

if you think brook stands no chance against paper punching pauli and 'i went over the hill and far away long before any of the teletubbies' zab judah, then yeah, you dont like brook or anyone to do with sky!

 

Brook/Peterson - hard to pick Brook coz he ain't been tested yet, whereas we know what Petersons got. Could be good.

Brook/McCloskey - Not bothered, stinker written all over it.

Brook/Judah - With Zab's age and sometimes questionable mentality being a factor i see Kell stopping or KO'ing him at some stage after some early problems.

Brook/Maidana - I think Brook on a clear points win maybe even a stoppage. Assuming his chin is ok. Personally i'd like to see this fight soon. Skillwise it won't be a problem for Kell but it will answer some questions about him.

Yep Khan needs to think before he speaks and as come across as a right tool for some time now.

 

the opening poster missed him of the poll but added him on the opening post! hes on there which is why everyone else gave there opinion on brook vs paulie

 

Peterson beats Brook

 

At this moment in time, and on the evidence so far Brook beats McCloskey in an ugly, ugly fight. In the future it may be different, especially as the fighters listed are all career LWWs and Brook looks like he'll eventually have to head up to LMW

 

Peterson would beat Brook and so would Khan.

 

BROOK VS PETERSON = Brook KO2
BROOK VS MAIDANA = Brook KO2
BROOK VS McCLOSKEY = Brook KO1
BROOK VS MALIGNAGGI = Brook KO3