Again bashing one of our greatest ever exports. Of course Calzaghe had a number of meaningless title defences, as is the same with ALL long reigning champions (he was at the top for 10 years ffs, anyone else who is at the top for that time always has the same.) I always think you need to look at what a boxer is doing before and then does after a fight to rate them accurately when looking at someone’s record. We all know what fights did before, but let’s look at a few of what Joe’s “overrated” wins did after; - Sakio Bika would remain a fringe contender at the top level and pick up a WBC world title - Kessler would stay at the top until retirement, win another title and be ranked at the top of SMW division until retirement. - Hopkins would beat undefeated and undisputed middleweight champ Kelly Pavlik in his next fight, before winning 3 more Light Heavyweight titles and staying at the top of the rankings until finally retiring 8 years later. He wasn’t perfect but let’s be honest he is a deserved hall of famer and a top top tier talent.