Calzaghe fans, throw down your top 10 wins.

this is just gunna turn into people taking each win and making it worse than it is

over the hill, old, overhyped .......

 

1. A prime Robin Reid, who by the way beat Calzaghe on my scorecard.
2. A weight-drained Chris Eubank, who in his next fight jumped 2 weight classes.
3. A 43 year-old version of Bernard Hopkins.
4. The one-dimensional, no-talent Mikkel Kessler who lost to the only 2 good opponents he faced.
5. Jeff Lacy, a hype job whose only semi-credible win was over a shot, comebacking Robin Reid.
6. Sakio Bika, a gatekeeper who has never beaten a good fighter.
7. A completely shot Roy Jones.

I honestly don't want to make you laugh any more.

 

We don't have the time and you don't have the boxing IQ to understand any way.

 

told ya so

 

Not a Calzaghe fan, but possible something like:

1 Mikkel Kessler
2 Bernard Hopkins
3 Jeff Lacy
4 Chris Eubank
5 Roy Jones Jr
6 Robin Reid
7 Byron Mitchell
8 Mario Veit I
9 Sakio Bika
10 Richie Woodhall

Botched together very quickly. You could move RJJ down, perhaps Veit I or Mitchell up.

 

Not really a fan, but here's how I'd rank them:

1) Hopkins
2) Kessler
3) Reid
4) Eubank
5) Lacy
6) Mitchell
7) Woodhall
9) Starie
9) Thornberry
10) Bika

That version of Jones doesn't even make the list.

 

the 2 veit legendary encounters surprised there was no rubber match to finally settle the score !

also the brutal murderous vicious knockouts of manfredo and mitchell !

 

You mind your own affairs. I'll post where I want to! I don't want to post here so I am not going to!

I am a higher ranked poster than you are, it is common knowledge.

 

In no order but 10 wins I give Joe credit for and why

1. Eubank - Joe came in as underdog and beat a fighter who had only lost to S Collins twice, 2nd time by SD yet Joe won big.

2. Reid a former WBC champ who had great nights and real off nights. For the first 4 rounds Joe outboxed him easily, then broke his hand, in the 4th and it became a good fight.
Reid went on to look unlucky against Ottke years later, and beat undefeated B Magee who is now European champ.

3. - Woodhall - A good fighter who had lost his title to Beyer in a hard fought fight. Beyer became 3 time WBC champ, yet Joe proved too much

4. Hopkins - was Ring LHW champ and P4P #3. Joes first fight at the weight and he won. Only 2 fights before Hopkins beat Tarver who had just beaten Johnson, & in Hopkins fight after he beat undefeated Pavlik.

5. Mitchell - 2 time WBA SMW champ who had beaten Liles, drawn and lost with 2 weight champ Girard, beaten Siaca who went on to become champ and only lost his belt by a disputable SD to Ottke in Germany.

6. Lacy - Joe was underdog to the undefeated IBF champ, yet put on a great performance and ruining Lacy it seems. People dont like to admit this but Lacy has arguably a better resume than current IBF champ Bute does now.

7. Jones Jnr - Still a Ring LHW rated fighter and not quite as shot as people would like you to believe as there was many before the fight picking Jones to win, I believe Haye, Froch and Hopkins among them.

8. Kessler - Undefeated WBC & WBA champ, who after losing to Joe has won and lost the WBA belt and won the WBC belt again.

9. Brewer - Had suffered many losses but always seemed to bounce back with a win that kept him highly rated. He fought Ottke to 2 SDs but Joe clearly. I probably wouldnt have Brewer in the top 10 but he is a recognised name for American fans, which is why ive put him in.

10. Tough knowing who to pick last. For the sake of a name that Americans will recognise ill say Bika who went on to win the contender series though he like Brewer might not have made it also, except for the fact he is recognised

I could make a case for Mkertchyan, Veit 1 & 2, and Starie to be mentioned in that list.
After those 14 names I would probably mention Sheika and Ring top 10 rated SMW Manfredo.