Joe would school Dawson. Tarver is very overrated. In fact Dawson has a good chance of losing to Diaconu. Joe is the best at 175.
Tarver also has horrible stamina, horrible! Chad though could still hurt Joe...ItÂ’s a pick em fight...
Calzaghe would easily exploit Dawson's horrible defence. As slow and old as Tarver is he was landing way to frequently. Dawson would experience a Lacy like beating against Calzaghe.
Like I have said elsewhere I think if they fight it will be a SD Calzaghe. Also, before this happens, Dawson needs to fight Johnson again, and Calzaghe would have to fight and beat both RJJ and Pavlik.