Calzaghe must be top 10 atg ?

YOU SCORED ROUND 1 TO REID?

 

Thank you! It must hate taken a long time to find that, I must keep a record of all my scorecards that disagree with an official verdict!

Yeah apparently I gave the first to reid when I scored it. I think 11 was the more debatable one tho, that's the one that ultimately won it for reid imo.

Once again, thank you for this.

 

it popped up third when i googled calzaghe reid round by round...

quite a stroke of luck actually.

there is no debate around round 1. reid did not win that round. he literally landed 1 scoring punch. you clearly have no idea how to score. :thumbsup

 

My rbr is number 3 on google splendid news!

Maybe 1 day i'll rewatch it and score it but for now it's staying as round 1 to robin.

Altho thanks to this conversation i've been trawling through my posts to find all my unofficial result scorecards so I can write them all down to hand. I'm still 14 scorecards short tho!

 

i suppose it makes you famous. :thumbsup

i was looking for other opinions (you actually had me doubting my memory/judgement for a second tbh) but when i saw that i knew it was just you being crazy. :good

dude...there is NO WAY you can score that round to reid. honestly. that is just madness. if reid won that round then haye beat wlad by shut-out.

glad i could help.

 

It was a good fight actually, quite underrated imo, so I probably will watch it again. But for now it's what it is :good

9 short now! Almost there. 35 fights altogether that I disagree with the official result. Found my old scorecards for all but 9. 34 are my scores and 1 is a result of multiple fight reports.

 

this we agree on. :good

 

Yeah when I watched it I was quite surprised how action packed it was, much better fight than i'd originally remembered!

You'll be pleased to know i've recaptured all my old scorecards that go against official decisions. Took a long time but after post trawling and folder notepad hunting i've done it I think.

I'm so happy

 

according to your logic, it's impossible for anyone to surpass joe's resume.

 

just incase anyone is interested, i've created a thread on classic that has all my diagreeing scorecards posted. due to the volume i've not included any rbr, but the final tallies are all there.

 

Cockzaghe has wins over ATG's Toeker Pudwell and Evens Ashira! Now that he is retired how will anyone surpass him?

 

Have Calzaghe haters turned now to a close fight that he had with Reid as their inspiration?atschatschatsch

 

i hope those other scorecards are less ******ed than your blatantly incorrect calzaghe/reid card.

btw. i don't believe calzaghe won cos the judges said he did...judges can get it wrong. he won cos anyone judging that fight fairly & without mental ******ation HAD to score that fight to calzaghe.

ypu gave EVERY close round to the challenger & gave reid a round that he couldn't possibly have won as he got outworked, outlanded & calzaghe held centre ring, forced the pace & defended better. you seem like a nice guy but you have no credibility. sorry. :good