Can Pac beat all version Mayweather fought? Can Mayweather beat all Pac fought?

If Floyd struggled with Castillo(at a weight which Floyd is better) and Zab(first few rounds until he gassed out), Cotto will give Floyd problems and could beat him at 147.

EM could give Floyd problems.

 

One name for ya peeps

Juan Manuel Marquez

aka Manny's daddy


:smoke

 

Mayweather - Morales would give Mayweather all he could handle, could possibly beat him...but I wouldn't favour him. Mayweather beats Barrera. Marquez would have been closer, but Mayweather still wins. He beats Diaz at 135lbs. Beats the De la Hoya who fought Pacquiao. Beats Hatton at any weight. Cotto before Margarito would give Mayweather a good bout...but I've always thought Mayweather would have too much for him. He beats Clottey, but it's not an easy night...maybe somewhat boring.

Pacquiao - Corrales height would make it interesting, but Pacquiao would have too much, probably stoppage. Castillo could be a tough one, especially if it turns into a war which is more than likely...even more-so if its Manny's first bout at 135lbs. Judah could be dangerous for a round or 2, but Manny would probably stop him. Pacquiao beats Baldomir, 147lbs version of Hatton, and Welterweight Marquez. De la Hoya and Mosley could be interesting...De la Hoya would be throwing, and had some success with the jab against Mayweather. Mosley would be dangerous early, and probably wouldn't have been so hesitant against an offensive Pacquiao...however the speed and angles could make him hesitant.

 

Ur talking bout an injured Floyd against Castillo in the 1st fight & Zab who won 2rds?? :think

Seriously, Cotto would get hit by everything Floyd threw while missing all night! Floyd at 130lbs was a beast and EM would be there for maybe 3rds just to eventually get picked apart... same w/Cotto!! You obviously haven't seen Floyd at 130-135lbs! MAB, JMM, & EM all would get whooped rather easily!! None of these guys have defense & Floyd had more speed & top shelf defense, chin, & adability!!

 

you're even overexxaturating his accomplishments at beating southpaws..

Zab Judah...really?atsch

 

An even matched fight vs "cherry-picking your opponent"

 

GOOD TO GO, RESPECT THAT:good SURE AS HELL CAN'T ARGUE WITH IT:thumbsup

 

Well he is undefeated against them. He does get thrown off by them some, but still dominates them. Zab was going to give Floyd problems even if he was orthodox in the first few rounds, but they knew he was going to gas out and that was their strategy and they used body shots to bring him closer to that

 

Pls... he beat Zab down along w/Mitchell who he floored & eventually stopped & lets not forget Corley!! He didn't just beat them, he dominated them & whopped ass!!

 

Yeah, Zab gave him problems for bout 2/12rds but then he went on to beat em down!! Floyd not necessarily starts slow but he basically takes a cpl rds to adjust & get his timing down then it's pretty much over!!

 

if i remember right, zab won rounds 1, 2, and 4, floyd won round 3...after that though it was pretty much all floyd

 

If we go by clean and effective punching, effective aggression, ring generalship, and defense, round 4 was all Floyd. All Zab did was land two flashy left hands, but the real punishment was all in the bodyshots Floyd gave to him. Zab won the first minute of the round, and Floyd won the last two minutes.

Round 1 was competitive but a Judah round. Round 2 was the best Zab Judah round in the entire fight.

One judge even had Floyd winning all but one round.

 

id just like to see floyd fight more often..

 

thats true.. but would floyd go undefeated now if he was to try to clean out the welterweights? he needs to fight more often to be the best..