Can Pac beat all version Mayweather fought? Can Mayweather beat all Pac fought?

too many points i don't agree here. i do admit that i cannot rate boxers from the beginning but how are you sure that floyd's resume at 147 is top 10 of all time? his best win is an aging mosley and you have baldomir next.

pacquiao has legacy at 122 pounds where he stopped almost all his opponents by KO. you could argue that it was almost all done in asia but this is where asians do dominate. also pac arguably beat barrera when he was still a 122 pounder since that was his first time to move up to feather.

marquez being p4p #2 doesn't mean **** when you are dragging that lightweight all the way to a catchweight welterweight fight and still not making that agreed weight. it's impressive win yes but consider all of this and it is a whacked fight.

the clottey win is at par with the baldomir or judah win. you could not spice-up that win for floyd as a far-impressive victory.

 

Mosley knocked the **** out of the real welterweight champion who has an iron jaw, nobody wanted to face Mosley after including Pacquiao, he was going to fight shitty Berto. Mayweather took the fight and beat him like it was a sparring match. Cotto looked like **** vs. Clottey and got a gift decision, Mosley was the #1 welterweight in the world and the real champion. Why didn't Pacquiao fight Mosley? guess he rather fight Mosley's leftovers.

 

I dont think Floyd would have problems with the 2 VERSIONS of Barrera that Pac fought tbh.

Mayweather would beat any fighter Pac ever fought, that goes without saying with the Morales of 130 that beat Pac making him work hardest.... Corrales at 130, Castillo at 135, Judah & Hatton at 147 & Oscar at 154 all have a realistic chance vs Pacquiao at those weights at the times Floyd fought them IMO.
Id pick Oscar over him at that weight & that night, personally.

 

With it being out there that Pac has rehydrations clauses in his contract, I wonder if Pac can really be Cotto, Clottey, De La hoya, and not to even speak of Floyd. With these fighters coming into the ring underhydrated most would fade after 3 rounds. They would suffer from lack of punching power and weak legs. Let get Pac Man back in the ring with some of these guys with no rehydration clause and if Pac Man beats them then restart the debate. Come pac no more tricks straight up fights even playing field.

 

Forget all that ****, start from the fights at 130 lbs were Floyd started his career.

 

atschatschatsch

 

did reading that **** made you cringe?

 

Your out of your fkn mind !

If Pac avoids getting knocked spark out vs prime Shane & Oscar, that is a result for him & Shane never ran from DLH in either fight, he won the 1st fight fair & square & lost the 2nd fight fair & square (**** the judges)... there was no running in either fight.

 

Your on pacs dick again phil, hop on off & start talking sense please atsch

 

No sweat. Pac beats everyone on Floyd's 130+ res, and Floyd beats everyone on Pac's 130+ res. No real doubt about it. The Pac who beat D.Diaz would burn Castillo for speed, and the welterweight version would trounce the old, tired, stamina-shorn versions of Oscar and Shane. The 130lbs Floyd would decision Marquez, Morales, the 147lbs Floyd would decision Cotto and Clottey. Stylistically, Floyd vs Margarito would be interesting, but I'd still back Mayweather to beat him.

 

There is no fighter on PAc's resume who could beat Floyd or give Floyd major problems. There are a few fighters on Floyd's resume who give PAc problems...real talk!

 

Prime example of that is in the second fight with Morales. Morales was winning the fight and next thing you know, his legs give out. Watch the fight again and watch Morales during the last rounds and watch him while he's in his corner

 

Morales, Barrera & Marquez are obviously better & greater p4p fighters than Castillo & Corrales but that doesnt translate into tougher to beat in H2H fights at certain weights, Corrales & Castillo were bigger & stronger men than EM, MAB & JMM.

Why the **** do I have to explain this to you pacfucs constantly ? :huh

Unbelievable !

 

do you seriously believe that morales and marquez at 130 was inferior to corrales and hernandez?

 

Mayweather would shut Margarito out via boxing clinic, the skill gap is astronomical.