Can Pac qualify in ATG list?

of course, hes been in mine for a while

 

he is an atg for sure

 

Name me the top 10 and I will compare Pac resume with them.

 

obviously an ATG. top 50 to 60

 

Pac is on the list for sure. He is the #1 pound for pound person in the sport at this moment in time.

 

SRR, oh wait let me guess he have more losses than pac, got beat by fighters with **** records. Has fought a number of cans uncomparable to mab, morales, jmm. And pac has lineal and is now in his 8th division, 3 lineals etc. etc. yeah right.

 

Yes, he'd be somwhere in my top 50

 

Go on then.

1. Ray Robinson
2. Harry Greb
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Sam Langford
5. Muhammad Ali
6. Ezzard Charles
7. Mickey Walker
8. Roberto Duran
9. Benny Leonard
10. Barney Ross

 

PBF is top 30 for me already. Too much nostalgia bias towards older fighters. PBF is considered the best of his generation and Pac will follow.

 

Benny Lynch. Take away the old fighter nostalgia and lets go by facts here. Take away all the bums he fought with 0 wins and 1 loss records and hes only fought 14 fighters with decent records. Now tell me who are his best wins? Is it Kirby? Who has 37 losses...ok different era blah blah blah, fact remains is if 37 before have beaten this man, what makes you so special for beating him? Jackie Brown is decent but again, anothe rguy who lost 14 times before Lynch beats him. When Morales looses to Raheem beforehand people use that against Pac as someone already beat him, why cant it be said for older fighters? This guy stayed in flyweight all his career, Pac soared from flyweight to LW and dominated throughout. This guy lost 12 times fighting only 14 opponents with decent records. He lost 6 times to fighters with 0-0-0 record or thereabouts after so many fights, can you imagine what would happen if Pac were to loose to a fighter with that record now?

There is no comparison. He is considered the best fighter Scotland has ever produced. Pac is in contention for the best fighter Asia has ever produced!

 

Boxrec records are quite flawed, the majority of the names with 0-0-0 records are false, and have simply to do with lack of information on Boxrec's part. Same thing with a guy like Jimmy Wilde and his resume. He fought for titles with guys who on Boxrec are said to have 0-0-0 records, when in reality they were known fighters in their times with over 40 fights.

But point taken. Pacquiao rates above Benny Lynch. I'd agree as well to be honest, he was just a name I decided to throw out.