What the heck is it with you guys and Carnera? He sucked. Fixed fights. You guys have him in every other thread. Do you think it is funny or cute? It isn't. It's pathetic and devalues the entire forum.
Suga Valuev big! He would beat Carnera into literal pulpy juice and use him to wash down the orphans he devours to sustain that mass.
I think Valuev would take the W. His record is better and against a better class of opponent. It would probably be a fairly dull affair, let's be honest. None of these guys set the world on fire.