Cazaghe better than Floyd?

well, thats your own opinion, so who cares? fact is they are 1-2. you can go do the research. as for castillo, what the hell is your point? castillo's win over corrales was tainted too. you added nothing new to this topic.

 

Have you watched Corrales-Casamayor 2?

It is because Castillo came as a JWW.

 

its got nothin to do with that. and its not just hernandez, chavez and augustus against woodhall, brewer and mitchell. it the opponents that they both fought collectively that judges the strength of their opposition.

 

and you are dumbest poster on ESB

 

again, you dont have a good sense of how to rate fighters. you cant compare hatton losing to pac when pac is considered a great fighter. do you think thopmson is great. if not, then you cant even mention them togehther because they are on completely different levels. hatton, was unbeaten and 5 pounds didnt change the fact that he was, at the time, considered and top 10 p4p fighter. most people agree that eubank was past it. he was on the downside. and if you deny that, then obviously your a calzaghe fan who is being unobjective. if thats the case, then all this is pointless

 

why do you keep bringing up things thatv had nothing to do with your topic? the point for you trying to prove that calzaghe has a resume on par with mayweather's. and so far, you havent prove anything. all you've done is make statements that cant be proven. you claiming that people discredit foreign opponents as to why calzaghe resume dosent get enough respect is you're own vain opinion and assumption. do people do that, of course, but this is the point here. the point is PROVING that the calibur of calzaghe's opponents is on par with mayweather's and you simply havent done that.

 

there is no need to because those are not only guys both mayweather and calzaghe have fought. and thopse are low level fighters anyway. and why did you conviently omit the better fighters each men fought. wince both men are champioship fighters, wouldnt you start with the championship level. lets pose the same question to you.

do you believe that Dlh, hatton, corrales, judah, castillo, marquez, corely, chavez, hernandez, gatti are as good or better then

hopkins, jones, kessler, lacy, reid, sheika, veit, bika, brewer, eubank

at the times they fought in their respective careers?

 

debatable, but you can have that, there are bigger points to hit.

you're clearly wrong. all three men were or became title holders while facing better competition then the guys you mentioned for calzaghe.of the four calzaghe opponents you mentioned, only 2 of them were won belts in their careers, not to mentioned how weak the smw division was at the time. and calzaghe stuggled mightly with reid while mayweatehr clearly beat the guys you brought up. and you can also throw in the name demarcus corley who was anoth title holder mayweather beat at 140.

corrales is not better then corrales? debatable

gatti is not better then lacy? debatable

hatton is maybe slightly better win than eubank? wrong, it clearly is, you can take a poll if you want

DLH is not better than Jones if yes then only financially? thats the dumbest thing you said yet.

Marquez is definitely worse than Hopkins? maybe but take into account how calzaghe struggled with a fighter who was elite, but elite at 43.

Manfredo Jr and Baldomir are both Cindirella man, edge to Baldomir for having linear title. that goes without saying. at least baldomir beat somebody relevant. he also has a win over clottey, in case you didnt know. so based on you're analysis, the only conclusion that can be made is that you're a calzaghe fan that is making case to prove that he is as great or greater then mayweather, while there resumes are similar, mayweather clearly beats him that category.

 

Firstly, hopkins whipped joe's ass and it's as cheap a win for joe as dirrell is for froch. Secondly, floyd would beat calzghe right now depsite the weight disparity. What difference does size makes if the bigger man hits like a *****?

 

48 - 0
40 - 0

According the floyd mayweather, calzaghe is better than him.