Cazaghe better than Floyd?

Yeah floyd is better than joe, no contest, talent wise its hard to top floyd but joe was a decent mover too

 

As Uncle Roger would say if anyone thinks Joe is better than Floyd Jnr they don't know **** about boxing

 

well, those 5 pounds would not have kept that left hook from putting hatton on his ass. put just to entertain your viewpoint, lets say for the sake of argument that hatton at 145, wasnt as good at 140. even if this was the case, you'd really put him on the level of eubank, being that eubank was past his prime when he fought calzaghe and retired a year later?

 

I don't think it's arguable Calzaghe was a very good boxer Floyd is a genius imo

 

Is that what joe says to make his biggest fights seem legit eventhough they came against past prime greats.

 

everything you said was true, but the point is, up until now corrales has accomplished more. 1-2 with casamayor and 1-1 with castillo(dont forget about the whole weigh-in fiasco in the rematch) is still pretty good. kessler hasnt exactly been in there with that type of competition. the fact of the matter is, mayweather's resume, while its missing some names, is still better then calzaghe's.

 

first off how do you know hatton is almost retired. who knows what his plans are. secondly, hatton won his two next fight after losing to mayweather. one of them happen to be against malinaggi, he won by tko. he did something that even cotto couldn't do, a guy who comfortably moved up to 147. while eubank lost two fights and was done. so common sense should tell you, both men were at different stages of their respective careers.

 

well, you dont know what the future holds. because after kessler-froch, mayweather-mosley will happen and if mayweather beats mosley. you going to have to give up this agrument completely. so you can only judge the present time. and even if kessler beats froch, that still doesnt necessarily put him over castillo.

yeah there's a difference. you seem to think its razor thin but when you really analyze their resumes there is enough difference to conclude that mayweather will be remembered and rightfully so as the superior fighter. but if you're a calzaghe fan or mayweather fan, its hard for you to be objective.