I think he was nearly as good as Lennox Lewis in the early 2000s. - Beat Holyfield by a wider margin than Lewis managed. - Beat a lighter version of Tua. - Both had trouble against Vitali, but ultimately got the win. - McLine, Oquendo and Williamson were about equal to Botha and Grant. - Byrd would have beaten Tyson and Rahman. - Byrd would stand a good chance against Lewis in a head to head match-up.
Disagree with these 2, but otherwise great post! McCline was better than Botha and Grant on his own imo, and so was Oquendo, so disagree there. Byrd would've been competitive with Lewis, made him look bad. I can't see him actually winning tho, especially against Lewis of 97 to 2000
I mostly agree with the first sentence. Which makes Byrd's resume seem even better. I am not sure whether Lewis could deal with Byrd. He never liked southpaws.
The only people that underrate Byrd are a few deluded souls who think shitting on Byrd devalues the Klitschkos. They know who they are. Byrd was excellent.
He beat a 40 years old Holyfield and an injured Vitali.Tyson would ko him ,Lewis would decision him easily in a bore fest. No he isn't underated.
- Byrd would have beaten the 2002 version of Tyson on points. No problem. - He beat the same version of Holyfield that Lewis beat. - Byrd was giving Vitali a lot of problems before the latter retired. The fight was very close, much closer than the scorecards indicated. That's impressive, given that Vitali is one of the best heavyweights ever. - Byrd was a stylistic nightmare for Lewis. That played a role in Lewis not fighting him in 2002/2003 in my view. I think Byrd would have won on points.
Byrd IMO was the receiver of wins by more than just one injured fighter.We know Vitali quit due to injury. Not Byrd's fault, but can't give him honors. http://www.espn.com/boxing/news/2002/1218/1479329.html Holyfield tore is rotator cuff early in the fight. I remember him saying a few times "rub ma' shoulder." Very good boxer. But both Klitschkos proved when healthy they were too big & strong, along with Ike who had him slobbering. His toughness was as good as his skill set. Lennox saw no desire to chase the guy around, I had no problem with Lewis bypassing him. He wanted the big boys Grant, Ruddock, Tyson, Holy, Bowe, Tua, Mercer.
Nope he beat a 2 years older Holyfield who had lost and drawn with Ruiz. I'm matching prime for prime ,and prime Tyson ko's Byrd. Lewis didn't fight Byrd because it would not have drawn flies,What evidence is there that Byrd would have been a stylistic nightmare for Lewis? Wlad who wasnt as good as Lewis ,beat a prime Byrd comfortably, flooring him twice,he wouldn't present problems for Lewis other than maybe stinking the joint out. Vital was clearly in front against Byrd when he showed a lack of the necessaries and quit.
- Holyfield was no different in the 2nd Lewis fight against Byrd. Holyfield took 4-5 rounds off Lewis. He could only take 3 rounds off Byrd. - Byrd and prime Tyson could go either way. - Lewis didn't like southpaws. Byrd was a southpaw. - Wlad matched up with Byrd better than Vitali and Lewis.
- Lewis was scheduled to fight Kirk Johnson in 2003. He knew Byrd was a harder match-up. - Byrd was giving Vitali a lot of problems. He won the 3rd, 5th, and the 9th. Rounds 6-8 were all close. I gave at least two of them to Byrd. Vitali won rounds 1,2 and 4. - Byrd matched up well with Holyfield, Lewis, Tua and Vitali. Not so well against Wlad.
He was 2 years older and had lost and struggled with Ruiz . What evidence can you show that Lewis would have any more problems with Byrd than Wlad did? In which way did Wlad match up better with Byrd than Lewis?
Wlad coped with southpaws better. Holyfield had beaten Rahman before facing Byrd. He was no more past-it in 2002 than 1999.
I'm not sure if he'd have beaten prime Tyson but post prison Tyson I think Byrd would have beaten by wide UD. Tyson simply wasn't throwing with the same speed, accuracy and combinations he had done before. Also, I want to say, he looked pretty good in his last fight, vs Povetkin. Byrd was against the wall facing a much younger and fresher opponent with ATG skills himself, and he really made Sasha work for the win.
Byrd had slowed down tremendously when he fought Povetkin. He still had heart though. One of the bravest boxers of all time.