Clarification Needed On Joe Calzaghe's ATG Ranking...

Shouldn't be hard to name 100 off the top of your head then...go!

 

calzaghe and mayweather are just a pair of prima donna pansies. neither hit hard enough to hurt a flea. But most of all BOTH their 0's are BOGUS!!!!
Pair of overrated cowards in my book

 

So name 100 :nod

 

Your trail ran cold at Smith beating JLC...

 

But he did :nod

 

Calzaghe had a few good wins and did what he had to but in my opinion his record is rather poor compared to a lot of other British fighters so I have no idea about atg status.

I wouldn't know where to start..

 

If we are going by that logic Audley Harrison has a claim to be the greatest of all time.

Audley Harrison beat Danny Williams who beat Mike Tyson who beat Trevor Berbick who beat Ali.

 

Calzaghe is the greatest to have ever fought in the super middleweight division

 

:nono

Why Joe is better than Harrison:

Joe Calzaghe beat Bernard Hopkins who beat Jean Pascal who beat Chad Dawson who beat Tomasz Adamek who beat Dominick Gunn who beat Audley Harrison :nod




Why Joe is better than Ali:

Joe Calzaghe beat Bernard Hopkins who beat Jean Pascal who beat Chad Dawson who beat Tomasz Adamek who beat Dominick Gunn who beat Tony LaRosa who beat Tevor Berbick who beat Ali :nod

Now find me a similar path as to why Joe is not the GOAT

 

All time he's barley good for this time ..

 

I have Slappy Joe around 278 in the ATG rankings and number 1 in the SMW rankings.

He might be the 5th or 6th greatest Brit of all time and 2nd greatest Welsh fighter of all time.

 

I tip my hat to you Mr Hans both of those are superb.

I love these "6 degrees of separation" type links, some are amazing :good


Let me have a think and I will get back to this.

 

he's not even an atg

 

:deal