Kelly Pavlik: (160) Arthur Abraham has the best chance, (168 ) Calzaghe, Kessler, Bute, and Mundine beat him. Floyd Mayweather: (147) Miguel Cotto beats him Joe Calzaghe: (175) Chad Dawson has the best chance, (168 ) Mikkel Kessler has the best chance in a rematch
No, it's not. Please explain why you think it's so ridiculous to have Cotto beating Mayweather. Mayweather has shown vulnerability to technical pressure, and nobody brings it the way Cotto does.
I don't think it's so ridiculous, Cotto has the biggest chance to beat Floyd from all 147lbers but I really don't think he can do it. PBF had problems with Castillo and Judah in first four rounds. Castillo was mauling PBF and fighting inside and Judah was boxing with him, countering him from his southpaw stance. Cotto fights from a mid-range and he is a paced fighter - giving Floyd time and space to use his superior defence and counter with solid shots.