Coming from a Pachugger, I think Cal breezed past Pac to get #2 pfp

who gives a **** about pound for pound lists when the supposed best fighter doesnt fight anyone worthy and will rather act like a fool on the WWE.

 

I don't know about that I watched Hopkins/Calzaghe again. I ignored HBO commentators and the fans. This time I was sober and scored the bout even or 1 point for Joe, I don't know whether or not to score that 7th round even or give it to Joe 10-9. Calzaghe is somewhere between #2 and #4.

 

I have to agree with this thread. I had JMM winning his 2nd fight with Pacman

 

i still have pac @ #2. he beat the #3 p4p fighter in jmm. calzaghe beat a top 10 p4p fighter in hopkins but hopkins is ranked much lower than jmm. calzaghe definitely has no. 3 p4p now pinned down ahead of marquez. jmm is still #4 since it was a very close fight w/ pac and he didn't lose that much in p4p status.

 

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. Marquez
4. Calzaghe

 

cotto has beaten A grade fighters but not yet a top 10 P4P fighter. to be considered in the top 3, he has to do that first. i have him at #5 though after pbf, pac, calzaghe and jmm.

 

PBF shouldn't be on folks' lists at all. Maybe it'd motive him to ****ing fight already.

 

I never expected Calzaghe to breeze through Hopkins. Hopkins is a sneaky ass fighter that is very tough to beat. I knew he would win but a close battle as he did.

PBF did have a couple of scratches in his fight against DLH.

Marquez was expected to have more of a shot to beat Pac than Morales or Barrera but we all knew he would have had to go into the jaws of the lion for it.

Pavlik I reserve opinion on until the next fight.

 

I do agree he deserves his ranking but as to Morales he beat him once and loss severely to him twice. I think twice more than equals out the once. I also think the Morales of that first fight beats Marquez. As to Floyd, a swollen eye and cheek are not superficial scratches (though he did win the fight, just not the blowout revisionists are trying to make it out to seem).