Yes Manny would do good against the same guys Floyd fought because after Floyd beat them they are never the same. Floyd took what was left in Oscar, beat Hatton and left the scraps for Pac look at the Lazcano fight after Floyd, and look at Shane struggle with Mora even he is naturally bigger and looked horrible against Pac and Pac didn't look good the last time he looked this bad was in the second fight with Barerra. So what you want about Floyd he wins and make it look easy Pac had to work his but off to beat Margarito who came off a year layoff and old Shane destroyed Margarito and Floyd would have embarrassed Margarito.
No it aint garbage yall just don't want get Floyd his props as being the best in this era or decade floyd aint fighting catchweight fights Floyd aint beating guys that comes off of tough loses or suspenspions Floyd is beating guys at there best Oscar was champ at 154, Hatton became a two division champ 140 and 147 and undefeated not like Pac struggling with a 39 year old who he couldn't who he finish after Floyd tore him up he didn't beat Shane like he beat Oscar.