This is a thread to nominate fights that played out in the same way, down to the shifts in momentum and the way the bout ended and in the way it was perceived or how it was scored (if it went the distance, that is). Here’s an example of what I mean: Vicente Saldivar v Howard Winstone 2 and Matthew Saad Muhammad v John Conteh 1 In both bouts, the British challenger built up a sizeable first half lead before the champion rallied in the championship rounds. In both fights, the decisive moment was in the 14th round when the champion knocked the challenger down twice. This was enough to give the champion a narrow win on the official scorecards. Can you think of some others?
Here’s another one: Arturo Gatti v Wilson Rodriguez was the modern equivalent of the first two Zale-Graziano fights (which were also companion fights of each other). Like those fights, the eventual winner was knocked down early in the fight (Gatti was down in the second round as was Zale in fight 1; Graziano was down in round 3 in fight 2), Gatti’s right eye was swollen shut like Graziano’s in fight 2 and he took a pasting through the first 4 rounds or so, as did Zale in fight 1 and Graziano in fight 2. The end came with a left hook (Zale-Graziano 1) and it was in the sixth round (both Zale-Graziano fights).
Isn’t Matthew Saad Muhammad-Yaqui Lopez II basically a replay of their first fight? And, similarly, MSM-Marvin Johnson I and II. Saad loved to play it back.
Both Colin Jones-Kirkland Laing fights. Laing was streets ahead then got caught in the same round by Jones. Both Andy Golota-Riddick Bowe bouts. Golota was kicking the tar out of Riddick both times then went crazy and got disqualified.
Spot on on both counts! Sometimes fights between the same two fighters play out the exact same way and Jones-Laing and Golota-Bowe are perfect examples. You could add Jones v Milton McCrory to that as well. McCrory built a big lead and Jones had a strong second half to take things to two very close decisions (draw, then split decision win for McCrory).
Guty Espadas v Alfonso Lopez 1 & 2 - both fights Lopez was ahead on points when Espadas lowered the boom in the same fateful 13th round. Donald Curry v Tony Montgomery and Carlos Santos - in both fights in the 5th round Curry's opponents fouled out via headbutting rather than get stopped. Even more amazing was these bouts were back to back.
Great stuff, Scar! The first one reminds me of Arguello-Escalera 1 and 2 but Escalera was behind on points in both fights but seemingly the momentum was with him as he came back before the fights were stopped in the 13th in Arguello’s favour. And speaking of foul outs, the infamous Norris-Santana fights where Norris managed to foul out twice with Santana laying comatose (or possibly pretending to, anyway) to win. Not sure anyone has ever won and then defended his title in this way.
Floyd Patterson vs. Sonny Liston, maybe the most famous instance of a rematch going exactly the same way as the first fight. Julian Jackson vs. Terry Norris and Julian Jackson vs. Agostino Cardamone. Both fights saw Jackson look slow and ponderous against a quick, smooth opponent for about a round and a half before he ended each one with the first real solid shot that he landed.
Naseem Hamed vs Kevin Kelley had a similar flow in action to Jose Zepeda vs Ivan Baranchyk where both fighters were dropped multiple times before the final knockout. Hamed vs Kelley both fighters shared 3 knockdowns and was stopped in round 4 while Zepeda vs Baranchyk shared 4 knockdowns with the fight ending in round 5.
Holyfield-Tyson II and “Mysterious” Billy Smith-Al Neill II. Both ended on DQ for biting (Smith’s being in the 10th round of a scheduled 20 after the two had fought to a draw over 20 rounds two months earlier). Smith kicked Neill before biting him, but he was always doing something mysterious.
I think the two Leonard-Hearns fights might have trodden similar paths if the second had been scheduled for 15 rounds.