Compare/contrast Pernell Whittaker and Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

I dont agree......Toney is'nt anywhere close to being the fighter that beat Evander Holyfield several years back......

Imo, Toney lost big in the first Rahman fight, he beat Peter by a point imo in his first fight with him, but then got completely dominated by him in the rematch.
The Rahman rematch was ruled a NC due to the early headbutt.....I'm not convinced Toney would have beat Rahman, in fact I'd say that Rahman likely would have taken that fight.

Toney is aging, and he's getting hit alot easier and alot more these days.
The man will never beat either of the Klitchkko brothers, because Toney is too damn old, the Klitchko brothers are too damn big, and they're pretty damn good boxers themselves.

For Gods sake, Holyfield performed better vs Oquendo than James Toney did.

The Oquendo fight was a robbery, it was even through the first half, and Oquendo just took over the second half. Easy victory for Oquendo, he won imo going away.



Did you see the Toney-Oquendo fight Scientist?
Interested in hearing your take?
If I scored big for Oquendo, you must have had Toney edging it!