Controversial Fights: Mayweather Vs Castillo I

Do you want us to score it like TFFP's thread?

Also good idea restarting the thread :good

 

Have to go out in a bit but I remember scoring this fight when I was still pretty 'green' as a boxing fan and scoring it for Mayweather 114-112, look forward to having another view. :good

 

took this from an old thread in general where I scored it.

1) Mayweather 10 - 9
2) Mayweather 20 - 18
3) Mayweather 30 - 27
4) J. L Castillo 39 - 37
5) J. L Castillo 48 - 47
6) J. L Castillo 58 - 58
7) Mayweather 68 - 67
8) Mayweather 78 - 75 (JLS deducted 1 point)
9) J.L.Castillo 87 - 85
10) Mayweather 96 - 94 (PBF deducted 1 point)
11) Mayweather 106 - 103
12) J.L.Castillo 115 - 113

So I has to 115-113 to Mayweather. 7-5 although i admit Castillo's round were clear wins, a few of Mayweather could go either way. I NEVER EVER SCORE EVEN ROUNDS BTW.

the commentary is very bias in this fight. I urge to score with the volume turned off.

 

Good stuff, was a great thread :yep

Will score this tonight hopefully :good

 

Haven't seen that fight in a long time...

I remember scoring it a close Mayweather win at the time but will re-watch and score again this afternoon!

 

Just got around to scoring it:

1. May 10-9 JLC
2. May 10-9 JLC
3. May 10-9 JLC
4. May 10-9 JLC
5. May 10-10 JLC
6. May 9-10 JLC
7. May 9-10 JLC
8. May 10-9 JLC (even round on my scorecard, JLC with a point taken off)
9. May 9-10 JLC
10. May 9-9 JLC (May's round on my scorecard, May with a point taken off)
11. May 9-10 JLC
12. May 9-10 JLC

Floyd Mayweather 114-114 Jose Luis Castillo

Very close and good fight, I can see how people can score the fight for either Mayweather or Castillo.

 

This was a week ago.

Sorry LHL, I'm not going to put any timeframe on it now. I'll just watch the fight whenever I get time :good

 

I'm in work and forgot to score it again.

I remember last time I scored it having it 2 rounds to Floyd.

For me I think Floyd definitely won it. It was close and Castillo pushed him, but I think it was more of a case of a bad day at the office for him rather than Castillo having his number. A point which I think is proven by floyd rematching him in his next fight and beating him more convingly (even though I remember it being scored closer :huh).

I think people just make more out of it than what actually happened because it's one of the only times you can pick a hole in his performance

 

Excellent fight, thanks LHL:good

Rnd FM JLC
1 10 9
2 10 9
3 10 9
4 10 9
5 9 10
6 9 10
7 9 10
8 9 9
9 9 10
10 8 10
11 10 9
12 9 10

112 114 to JLC

 

The result of the fight have anything to do with your love of the avatar ? ??? :hey

 

only saw this fight once and thought it deserved a draw! I was high and drunk at the time.

 

Great basis for scoring a fight then