Cotto No.1 without the PBF fight?

At the end of the day, Mayweather is, and probably always will be a better fighter than Cotto.

Hate on him as much as you like, I dont like him myself, but he is a grade above any other active fighter, and regardless of who they fight respectively will remain the better p4p fighter. Unless of course, he does deteriorate and loses.

 

well i Guss will just have to tell PAC cotto and cal. that it dose not mater what you do pbf will be p4p #1 even if you guys fight the best in your devision and pbf fight easy meaningless fights. pbf will #1

 

If Cotto fights another elite opponent and beats him after fighting Margarito (assuming he beats Margarito) and Floyd does indeed take a rematch with Hatton after the Oscar fight, you can make a very good argument for it.

 

That's just silly.. How can you say Mayweather will always be the better fighter than Cotto? He might have some better skills than Cotto, but saying he'll remain the best p4p fighter regardless of fighting in rematches with de la hoya and hatton is just stupid.. How can you remain the better p4p fighter when you don't even fight p4p contenders? We have seen Floyd's skills and yes, they are good, but I wanna' see how he fares against Cotto, Margo, or even Mosley.. If he doesn't fight Cotto after De La Hoya and insists on a Hatton rematch, then he will not remain the best p4p fighter, nor the best WW..