Could McCallum have beaten Hagler?

I definitely don't see a TKO, but I definitely do see Hagler winning a decision.

 

Close close fight. If Hagler is tentative and too respectful like he was vs Duran, we could be in for an upset here. Prime Hagler wins, but the 1985-87 version was slipping and could get outworked by the seasoned McCallum.

 

Agreed.

 

:good.

 

No Marvin wins hands down

 

What does hands down mean in your eyes? Convincingly? I can't see the Hagler who fought Mugabi having an easy time with McCallum. Considering how well Mugabi boxed against Hagler for 5-6 rounds. And McCallum certainly has better durability than Mugabi down the stretch.


McCallum is just flat out better than Mugabi across the board. Especially when it comes to boxing and picking punches with either hand. He's also slicker and more clever defensively.

 

Good post.

McCallum was a technician who would match Hagler there, although that ambidexterity would've been a problem in Hagler's sharper years. Mike had height, a pop, worked the body very well, and could compete at 160 easily. Hagler's determination would meet its match in Mike's fierce Jamaican pride. Prime for prime, I'd lean towards Hagler -too sharp, too strong, too complicated. But the 1985 version against a prime MW Bodysnatcher? Well... that would be a toss-up.

...And McCallum's holding a grudge against Hagler:

[yt]abmZoQRxRrc[/yt]

 

Beat me to it :good

I just watch the entire interview and it's pretty interesting to hear the Body Snatcher. He's still bitter about being avoided by the Fab4.

 

Hagler's footwork would've been the main difference. He was just more fluid a boxer and mover than McCallum, and at least matched, if not held outright edges, in most of McCallum's strong points.

 

Good post. We can add that both fighters are well-rounded and have no real weakness but I guess McCallum is smarter and more adaptable, specially against a '85-87 Hagler version who has considerably slowed down.

Hagler could do everything well but a bit slower and he wasn't specially hard to hit at this stage of his career.

A prime McCallum is another cat. He's in the same class than the likes of Toney and Hopkins as brilliant counter punchers. McCallum is strong, punches hard and knew where and when to hit. His subtle head movement, matched with strong chin, vicious body punching and good left hook makes a rough night for every 154 lbs fighter who ever lived.

Neither man could intimidate the other IMO. Hagler is slightly superior physically but McCallum is just the smarter of the two. He could win a long tactical contest of controlled agression.

 

McCallum had clear weaknesses, as exposed by the likes of Kalambay, Curry, Graham, etc.

Basically, the skilled boxer/mover type was always an issue for him to figure out. If you were within range throughout the fight, you were in trouble. If you could box well defensively or on the move, or just had a speed advantage, he'd have trouble finding you and getting set.

 

Prime Hagler is a clear level above McCallum, who was a solid pro and good technician who gets overated by the the more nostalgic. I think the opinion of these types of fighters' skills, because they were overshadowed, gets overinflated to compensate, and Mac is definitely one of those. Solid fighter, not great by any stretch.

McCallum against Hagler who fought SRL is a very interesting fight however. Could go either way. Speed kills old fighters. Mac wasn't paricularly fast, or that clever. Wily old Sumbu TOYED with the guy. I think I would give an old Hagler the edge in a brawling fight towards the end. The speedier middles of the say could have done the job however.

 

Pea, quick refresh of the memory. The opening post was the Hagler who fought Mugabi going up against McCallum. Not a prime Hagler.

And no way did Hagler have the legs after the Hearns fight to consistently do an "in and out" job, relying on speed and counters like Curry or Graham over the course of the entire fight. I feel a prime Hagler could accomplish this somewhat. And IMO a prime Hagler was still within range often, with the ocassional skipping out or range, then coming back into range with steady educated pressure.