craziest A beat B beat C, so therefore A beats C scenarios:

nope , Baldomir would beat hagler

Baldomir beat Judah, who beat Spinks, who beat Mayorga ,who beat Forrest, who beat shane, who beat Vargas, who beat Winky, who beat Tito, who beat Camacho, who beat Leonard, who beat Hagler.....therefore....you know it!!:good

 

this one's good.:good

 

:rofl

 

youre missing the point,its meant to be absurd and fun.
I think that was a good one by Sues.

 

Thats good.

 

We did this one time and had Ricardo Lopez beating John L Sullivan.

 

And there are variations of that rule:


a) Mayweather beat Castillo, not by much. Hatton destroyed Castillo. Many said Hatton would beat Mayweather, but were wrong.

b) Hatton beat Collazo, not by much. Mosley clearly beat Collazo. Cotto beat Mosley, not by much. For some people, this means that Cotto is better than Hatton (thing that we don't know unless they fight).


**The McBride beating Ali is the craziest.

 

we KNOW Cotto is better than Hatton :yep

 

I think Cotto is better than Haton, as most people do. But nobody knows it because that fight has not happened.

 

oh i see,you were mixing it further:good

 

The whole Mayorga beat Forrest still drives me crazy. I dont understand how a guy that completely dominated Mosley could lose to Mayorga. TWICE!!!
Thats what i love about boxing. It makes no sense at times.

 

Mayorga beats Forrest, Forrest beats Mosely, Mosely beat Vargas, Vargas beat Winky, Wnky beat Tito, Tito beat Mayorga.......and 'round it goes

 

Verno Phillips beat Cory Spinks who beat Ricardo Mayorga who beat Vernon Forrest who beat Shane Mosley

So Phillips obviously beats the **** out of Mosley 9 out of 10 times:yep

 

Jeff Ford > Tye Fields > Bruce Seldon > Tony Tucker > Oliver McCall > Lennox Lewis

 

God these are great. Nothing like perverting logic.

Mayweather > Mitchell > Phillips > Tszyu > Roger Mayweather > Pazienza > Duran > SRL.

Obviously Floyd crushes Sugar Ray, and reasonably, Hagler and Hearns.