Has there ever been an ESB list compiled? I have my own personal list of people I would never want working if I were fighting. Does anyone have any names to add? Pierre Benoist (Paul Williams vs. Sergio Martinez) Tony Crebs (Adrien Broner vs. Daniel Ponce De Leon) Alan Davis (Ali Funeka vs. Joan Guzman) Duane Ford (Manny Pacquiao vs. Timothy Bradley) Jerry Griffen (Delvin Rodriguiz vs. Ashley Theophane) Dan Kelley (Emanuel Augustus vs. Courtney Burton) John Mariano (Christopher Martin vs. Chris Avalos) Russell Mora (Mares vs. Agbeko) Manuel Oliver Paloma (Helenius vs. Chisora) Tony Paolillo (Juan Carlos Burgos vs. Rocky Martinez) Robert Pagonelli (Emanuel Augustus vs. Courtney Burton) Giuseppe Quartarone (Helenius vs. Chisora) Garry Ritter (Delvin Rodriguez vs. Ashley Theophane) CJ Ross (Manny Pacquiao vs. Timothy Bradley) Jerry Roth (Rios vs. Abril) Benoit Roussel (Ali Funeka vs. Joan Guzman) David Sutherland (Delvin Rodriguez vs. Ashley Theophane) Glenn Trowbridge (Rios vs. Abril) Jack Woodburn (Carl Froch vs. Jermain Taylor) Marlon Wright (Librado Andrade vs. Lucian Bute) #11
Jerry Roth scored Pacquiao Bradley 115-113 (too close for me). Scored Rios-Abril for Rios, as did Glenn Trowbridge. Roth also scored Alexander-Kotelnik for Alexander, 116-112. Hoyle, Trowbridge, and Moretti scored Marquez-Pacquiao 3 (one a draw, the other two for Pacquiao). Hoyle and Moretti scored Ortiz-Peterson a draw (Moretti 94-94 and Hoyle 94-93).
Giuseppe Quartarone and Manuel Oliver Paloma scored Helenius/Chisora to Helenius 115-113. I scored it to Chisora 120-108. Duane Ford and CJ Ross scored Pacquiao/Bradley to Bradley 115-113. I scored it to Pacquiao 117-111. Roberto Ramirez Sr. and Jose Ignacio Martinez scored Sturm/Macklin to Sturm 116-112. I scored it to Macklin 118-110. James Jen-Kin scored Mares/Moreno to Mares 120-106. Maybe the worst score among all of these listed, really. I scored it to Mares 114-112 (would've been a draw without BS KD and point deduction... Mares' ass should've had multiple deductions before Moreno got his out of nowhere... but that is for another thread). Jerry Roth and Glenn Trowbridge scored Rios/Abril to Rios 116-112 and 115-113 respectively. I scored it to Abril 120-108.
No idea who is corrupt or not, but the ones below are definitely guilty of incompetence: Russell Mora has to be up there after Mares vs Agbeko. Alfedo Perez also comes to mind after the insane Williams vs Airich match. Howard Foster seemed to help Hatton recover at a critical moment in the Lazcano fight. Mercante Jr should have stepped in much more quickly to stop the Whitaker vs Hurtado match, because the way it ended looked dangerous. He also behaved quite strangely in Cotto vs Foreman.
I like this idea. Make the name of the incompetent and/or corrupt judges public so people can know who they are. May not make a big difference but the more people know who these idiots are, the less we may see of them. :twisted:
someone needs to sticky this thread, ive been calling the clowns out for years. this guys stands out as one of the worse i have ever see. put a 500 dollar ref in the ring to overseas million dollar fighters....smart move = khan vs peterson ref, last This content is protected