r/Boxing's P4P List - Oct 2020 vs the first P4P top 10 compiled by the ring magazine, who from the current top 10 (r/boxing list) would have cracked the 1989 list or vice versa, era for era, which list contained/contains more quality? 1 Canelo Alvarez 53-1-2 - 2 Naoya Inoue 20-0 +2 3 Terence Crawford 37-0 - 4 Errol Spence Jr 26-0 +1 5 Oleksandr Usyk 18-0 +1 6 Vasyl Lomachenko 14-2 -4 7 Teofimo Lopez 16-0 New 8 Tyson Fury 30-0-1 New 9 Manny Pacquiao 62-7-2 -1 10 Gennadiy Golovkin 40-1-1 -3 1989 list: Pound For Pound Mike Tyson Julio Cesar Chavez Pernell Whitaker Michael Nunn Antonio Esparragoza Meldrick Taylor Azumah Nelson Raul Perez Virgil Hill Marlon Starling
As of 2021, but names from that Oct. 2020 list? Manny obviously Canelo possibly Maybe: Loma Inoue TC But why haven't they updated it as of 2021?
People were putting Spence on the list after beating Brook. It took a single world title fight for people to throw Spence on the list. I can't think of many other fighters who got the same treatment. At least with Lopez he beat a top 5 p4p fighter.
