Current Top 10 P4P List

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Paul Williams
5. Miguel Cotto
6. Shane Mosley (who's way to high as it is)
7. Chad Dawson
8. Wladimir Klitschko
9. Juan Manuel Lopez
10. Lots of people can go here.

 

Agree with what he's done, but it hasn't been against quality opposition to rank in the P4P list. No one's blaming the K bros, but if there's no quality opposition, then they just don't get on the list. It's the way it is. Now, if by some miracle, some good opposition comes along (say they fight each other), then whoever wins might climb up a notch or two.

Again, same thing with Kelly Pavlik. He started out on some folks' P4P list, but as he hasn't faced any decent opposition since JT (and lost to BHop), he is rarely found on a current list.

 

I disagree. Wlad has to be in the top 10.

Mosley is in the top 5 on most list based on one win.

He lost to a guy who wasn't in the list (Cotto) then wasn't in the list prior to fighting Margo. Yet jumps to 5?

 

1 Manny Pacquiao
2 Juan Manuel Marquez
3 Floyd Mayweather
4 Bernard Hopkins
5 Shane Mosley
6 Władymir Kliczko
7 Paul Williams
8 Chad Dawson
9 Nonito Donaire
10 Miguel Cotto

 

Paul too low. Mosley too high. Wlad too high.

Mayweather shouldn't be on there.

 

No he isnt grabage, having him in the top ten when he hasnt beatten a top 50 p4p fighter is grabage. hell based on what he might do??? p4p is based on what you have done.

 

Beating smaller and past prime rivals isn't quite my definition of p4p fighter. Dishandling bigger, highly regarded (then) foes is.

Wlad is beating **** out of all the challengers out there. Yes, he is boring and stiff, but his wins are legit. He defeated all kind of fighters: punchers, sluggers, boxers, southpaws you name it, and recently he dominated #3 HW in the world. Wlad is a p4p material.

Well, if somebody doesn't have him on his chart it's fair for me. But I think that with Mayweather on, p4p list are more interesting.

 

1 pac
2 hops
3 jmm
4 cotto
5 ssm
6 pw
7 c dawson
8 jml
9 rafa marquez
10 ivan calde

 

At least rank him higher than Mosley who somehow made the jump from not on the list to 5 with one win.

Wlad does deserves to be on the list. Just slightly high. All good though :good

:good Fair enough.

 

top 5

1. Pac
2. JMM
3. Hopkins
4. Cotto
5. Mosley

6-10 (no order)

- Donaire
- John
- Dawson
- Williams
- Calderon

 

I will consider that cheers!

 

1. Pacquaio
2. Hopkins
3. JMM
4. Cotto
5. Wlad
6. Williams
7. Dawson
8. Kessler
9. John
10. Abraham

 

no donaire in top ten?