Dan Rafael's #P4PRank Thoughts: P4P best of the last 25 years

Pac has a better resume and accomplished more than Marquez. Nobody can realistically put Marquez ahead of Pac.


The only thing Chavez has over Whitaker is more title defenses against cab drivers and that 80 winning streak, and Whitaker showed him why that record is a joke by embarrassing him 10 rounds to 2. Only thing Oscar has over Whitaker is winning more belts in more weight classes. A shot to ****, coked out Whitaker took a prime, young Oscar to school. Nobody has ever legitimately beaten Whitaker in his prime across 4 weight classes.

 

3. Bhop?atsch

 

Yeah I don't get that either. I don't look at those lists. They are meaningless. People find there own "special"criteria!

 

Ricardo lopez has to be the most overrated boxer ever. His resume makes Calzaghe's look like JCC sr's

 

Besides Morales being too low its a good list

Top 5 are interchangeable

 

Theynare up there but not over Jones

 

In his prime Jones was on another level.

 

while this list is far from perfect, a lot of the posts in this thread are even more ****ing stupid tbh.

hopefully we can all at least agree that GGG has no place anywhere near the list at this moment in time (and i'm a bit of a GGG fanboy myself). i personally don't think kovalev belongs there either, although he's closer than GGG obviously. bradley has a better resumé than either, as do a few of the others mentioned.

for what it's worth, while i'd mess with the order some i more or less agree with the top 10, 'cept i'd probably stick lennox in there for lopez.

 

I can name 50 guys who deserve to be on that list before Bumlovkin...

 

Bradley should replace lil g

 

I never believed in P4P rankings............................

 

You also never believed that the Earth is round.

Lol..

 

Who even takes BSPN seriously these days?

 

Chavez faced and beat the best of his generation.
Fighters like Rosario, Camacho, and Taylor are missing in Whitaker's resume, and those are really the top 3 major players at 135-140 during that era.

How would Whitaker have fared against true speed demons like Taylor and Camacho is somewhat of a question mark for me.