That's obvious, and kind of the point of my post. It's what their records should be with honest scoring, if you genuinely believe Smith beat Ryder, then that means you're wrong and have no idea how to score a match.
I don't know if you know this but one person can't score a fight a UD. And there was plenty of people who was closer to you (ie at ringside) who thought Smith edged it, including prominent journalists who have forgotten more about boxing today alone than you'll ever know
I haven't scored any fights split decisions and majority decisions, because I'm not a schizophrenic and I don't have multiple personality disorder.
A case could be made that Jacobs fights down to his competition at times. If there is a trend that Ryder fights up to his, then that would suggest a tough night for Jacobs. I will be picking Jacobs. I would be surprised if it werent competitive though. The years go quick. Jacobs is getting old. Not sure where either go from here win or lose to be honest.
Think I answered this on another thread but Danny Jacobs is post prime, and if recent showings indicate anything, he will burst due to the pressure.
Juan Ryder should be on a seven fight win streak bare minimum Patrick Neilsen 29-1 KO5 Jamie Cox 25-1 KO2 Andrey Sirotkin 16-0 TKO7 Bilal Akkaway 20-0-1 TKO3 Callum Smith 26-0 LUD12 but it should be WUD 12 And a brace of wins over two tough journeymen in Mikey Guy and Jozef Jurko, the later of whom is a LHW/CW And Juan could/or rather should be undefeated in his last 13, since 2015 because he's been robbed more time than a bank Good match up and a tough fight for both, at least on paper it is.
The problem here is that short phrase you posted,,,,"at his best", That's been in the rear view mirror for a while with Jacobs.