Who takes this one at there best? I prefer gatti as a fighter in most ways I would just side with green to take this he was a big light welter who was also solid at welter and the natural size and toughness would bring him through i think
That is exactly how I broke this down. There isn't much between them in fighting heart and skill level. They would both just punch until the final bell rings. But as you said, Green was a big junior welter who really used every bit of his physicality on his opponent. In a barn-burner I would side slightly with Green.