They are both pretty average for their time, but Price has far more power, and is much bigger, so Price by early KO.
Very hard to even imagine what would happen to poor Pricey if Shavers connected with a wide overhand right.
"Of course price win, he is so big." Quoted from Big Modern Heavyweight is far better than yesteryears.
Shavers might actually knock out a spectator with Price's flying head, giving the crowd a tremendous 2 for 1 knockout deal.