David Tua vs. Joe Louis , who wins and how ? ,public poll added.

What a ******ed thing to do (but common here) to compare the men whom hurt Louis to David Tua based on punching power or punch resistance .

 

I did not claim they threw combos like Louis did , but they could hurt their opponents about as hard. Rahman had a bigger punch and a better chin , which equalize his disadvantage in combinations , Even Maskaev would not have been downed as much as Louis was against Louis' opposition , the opposite can not be seriously claimed , except the likes of SuzieQ , femalen , Sweat Pee and janitor.

 

Louis was no Lewis and Tua was no Baer.
And Tua is more similar to Louis himself in a style than to a brawler with limited skills , but the question here is not about the skills

 

Of course janitor always writes the opposite from the truth

He is patient and waits for the best opportunity to land his bombs , he did have skills , its simply his lack of range that limited his ability , his defense is underrated .
Tua is somewhere between Louis , Foreman , Tyson , Marciano and Frazier.
Nothing like Chuvalo or Max Baer and light years ahead of Tony Galento in his abilities .

 

Just a usual Tua fight , Tua behind on points until he finds his opponent and blasts him to concussion .

 

What a load of crap.
janitor means Tony Galento hit as hard as Tua.

Elite for the 175lbs or maybe even 190lbs divisions , not ("even") for today's 201lbs+ division.

Jack Sharkey , Billy Conn , John Henry Lewis could in no way compete against today's big men , they would have either ducked the Klitschkos themselves , or got obliterated by them in spectacular career finishers .

Walcott #1 , Schmelling and Marciano come to mind , especially the first 2.

Your way of admitting he had a leaky defense ?

Because Tua could both land and take much harder punches than these lightheavyweights or light cruiserweights , I know the likes of you will never comprehend this.

 

Lewis proved he could take punishment as he proved against Mercer , Holyfield (twice) , but most of all against Shannon Briggs.

This is what he did the best , but not exclusively if you watch carefully enough.

Didn't claim he was a Louis replica or wannabe .

But still way better than Louis' defense.

Then you should try and learn from her , if you want to be a fighter , that is.

This is because you are janitor :yep