I think the ruddock who slug it out with Tyson in 1991, wins the fight by a very close decision. While this Tyson was not as good as the one who destroyed Michael Spinks, He retained his speed - he was only 25 - and his power, he would always be strong and hit hard, (but he had abandoned the style and substance that had brought him to the top.) And he was certainely IMO better than Tua in almost everything. Vicious slugfest with Ruddock ultimately picking up the victory. But but make no mistake, david would put up a hell of a fight.