Yes as long as the standards for getting into the HOF stay the same as they are then yes Cotto is in there. No reason not to put him there he has one of the best resumes for a current boxer and beat a HOF'er. 3 division champ too so of course he's in.
Serious? I think you should take a look at some of the names already in the hall of fame. A 3 division champion is pretty impressive in itself.
I would like to see him beat Margarito.....forget Pac he will never avenge that loss but the Margo one is within his reach if he wants it bad enough.....but even if he never fights Margo again i think he is HOF worthy no doubt...
Cotto is junior middleweight paper champ. He won his two other titles undeservedly in vacant divisions. He didn't work for it.
Three weight champion with some impressive victories, the defeats won't stop him from being a HOF, just an ATG.