watching it live me and my friends had cotto winning alot more rounds than he actually did (due to the fact that we'd been on the **** for 12 hours, had the sound turned down, lots of people chattering amongst themselves in the same room and more importantly; we all wanted cotto to pull off the upset!) the fact that he had any success at all had us all weighing up things in a totally biased fashion, but from what i've read everywhere, apparently no-one else saw it that way..... i'm yet to rewatch it, but i guess we were waaay wrong
The fight looked more competitive than it ultimately was, but its hard to say that he dominated Cotto. I'd lean more towards that than no however.