Did Fluid beat any ATG fighters who were in their prime?

canelo

close thread

 

JMM. Corrales. Castillo. Hatton. Cotto.

Boxing fans are ****s whe. it comes to losses.

 

Did Pac beat any ATG fighter in their "prime"?

 

ATG means 'All Time Great', not 'A Talentless Ginger'

Barrera.

 

Barrera was not in his prime. I forgot but he had some serious surgeries before that fight.

 

Many great fighters never beat a "prime all time great." Very few have beaten more than one. And there are always different levels of nitpicking you can always do, beginning with "what qualifies an ATG?"

Which multiple prime ATG's did Lennox beat? Hagler? Hearns? Chavez? Calzaghe? Holmes? Vitali/Wladimir?

 

Barrera was not prime and the Marquez fight was HIGHLY debatable. I haven't studied 2 enough but 3 Marquez should have won. And didn't Floyd beat Marquez around the same time. You did say prime atg right? Yes I know there was a weight jump but he was still in his prime right?

 

It doesn't count when you make your opponent climb 2 weight classes then proceed to cheat him on the scales.

 

Yeah that's what I was talking about. Barrera was many fights in. Barrera is pretty overrated anyways tbh. Do you really rank him as an ATG? Really? Because of his fights with Morales?