Tonry was pretty damn good as a hw to be honest, 03 version of Toney takes Whyte to the Shoulder Roll Hotel!
Yh and Whyte isn't overrated? The same Whyte who can't even throw a combination without stumbling all over the place losing his balance each time he attempts to throw any? Even if Toney is 'overrated', being 'overrated' is totally relative. In no world where a guy can make you miss by inches standing only a few inches away from you whilst being able to throw counter-punching combos ON THE FRONT FOOT is more overrated than a guy who can't even maintain his balance each time he throws more than 2 punches.
James Toney is one of the most skilled boxers ever, that's probably why you nugget. When he was on form, he was incredibly hard to beat.