Disputed decisions between 2 top fighters from past 10 years (TOP 5)

That whole trilogy was full of controvesay because I wasn't sure that Vasquez deserved the stoppage in the second fight ... and we just talked about the third fight ... the only clear victory came in the first fight ... when Vasquez quit !!

 

You need to learn how to score a fight man and not let your bias for Marquez cloud your judgement. Izzy won that fight fair and square. And even if he didn't get the extra points for the low blow deduction and the knockdown I still would've had Vazquez winning the fight by a point.

Besides, I don't see any fans disputing that decision so you're out on an island all on your own.

 

What fight were you seeing man .... you sound like you have bias ... I haven't revisted that fight in a while but the way I seen the fight Vasquez needed a knockout to win that fight. The 12th round was crucial but Philla is right ... you need to factor all 12 rounds not just one and if thats the case then Marquez deserved to win that fight.

 

JMM vs Barrera was closer than the cards suggested but JMM was a clear (ish) winner

 

what bias for Marquez? I scored that fight for Vasquez.

I was just saying it was a disputed decision. Last I checked even one of the judges gave it to Rafa. It sounds like you're the one who is biased, not me.

 

1.Trinidad vs Delahoya 2.Lewis vs Holyfield I 3.mosley vs Delahoya II 4.AyalavsTapia II 5.Pacquiao vs Marquez II

 

Funny how DLH fans are quick to point TIto's and Mosley fights but tend to forget about his fight with Sturm (among a couple more probably)... BTW, TITO WON!!

 

Tito, as I mentioned in another thread, was given a one-sided beatdown and a schooling by Oscar.


I scored the second Shane-Oscar to Oscar, but it was close and could have been called either way. No robbery.


And I scored the Quartey fight a draw.

Also the Sturm fight was either a draw or a loss for Oscar.

 

Morales-Barrera II
DLH-Mosely II
Marquez-Pacquiao II
Sturm-DLH

All wrong decisions IMO with the Pac-JMM II fight being the closest but still a close but clear Marquez victory.

 

Your now officially my best friend

Erik was ****ed up the ass by the judges in that trilogy, he is the better fighter both H2H & career wise IMHO.

 

Good call on that one. That decision was ****in' terrible, but gets forgotten a lot on these kind of discussions, I guess 'cause it's not as "high profile" of a fight.

Also, Casa vs. Santa Cruz. About the same level of disgusting.:yep