Do any GGG fans think he could have been competitive against the following:

I believe he can be competitive against most of them. I think Toney gives him the hardest fight of those listed.

 

Yes but let's keep in mind, many of the boxers listed were gigantic for the MW division.

 

Hell no name a good fighter girlie g beat ?
All of the aboved mention would knock one of those g off his name. Girlie g is atg tomato can bum.

 

I think he would have been competitive, beating those names is another thing.

 

Hagler-yes his chin gets tested
Roy Jones- in his prime beats him
Duran-beats Duran
Bernard- Hopkins out thinks him but has a rough start like first 4-5 rounds
Sugar Ray- it's a toss up
Toney- toney is probably the 2nd hardest fight for GGG outside of prime roy
Hearns- I think GGG beats hearns for some reason I think Hagler beats GGG though
Joe C. - could win but my money would be on GGG

Just my opinion not all will agree but yeah. That's fcking life

 

Competitive? Yes, absolutely.

As @N17 pointed out, winning is another thing.

 

He beats Duran rather easily

 

I'd have a few things a little different myself of course, but very good analysis.

 

If duran can beat a monster like barkley fighting girlie g would be like cholo spanking his kids.duran takes him to schoool and girlie g says no mas

 

Just for interest, since you are a good poster, this is how I see it:

Hagler: could go either way
Roy Jones Jr: toughest fight, can't see GGG winning
Duran: Think GGG wins
Hopkins: Tough stylistic challenge but I feel that GGG was perhaps better than the 160 lb version of Hopkins. At higher weights, Hopkins by UD.
SRR: very hard to compare people so far apart in time, rather not comment.
Toney: second hardest fight, pick Toney
Hearns: Agree, I feel GGG wins
Joe C.: Close fight, 50/50 IMHO. Maybe prime GGG can get enough KDs to win or a KO, I don't know.

 

L Hagler - Competitive but clear victory by Hagler
L Jones Jr - Wide UD
W Duran - KO
W Hopkins - just, this is probably close to a 50:50 fight
W Robinson - pretty even fight
L Toney
W Hearns - KO
L Calzaghe - we haven't seen how Golovkin looks at 168 which makes this even more difficult to assess
..whilst we're at it..
L Monzon

 

We agree on all but Hagler lol, and Hopkins I know Hopkins will figure him out only thing is will it be soon enough or will he have given up too many rounds.