DO YOU AGREE with 117-111 from Burt Clements & 116-112 from Dave Moretti?

I had it 115-113 Mayweather. But there were about five close/swing rounds. So depending on whom you score those rounds for you could have a score of anywhere from 115-113 Maidana to 118-110 Mayweather. But I think both those extremes show bias. In conclusion I think those scores were fine.

 

floyd won rd 2.

 

115-113 floyd is justifiable, but the fight should be a draw. 115-113 maidana is also ok if you give those swing rounds to chino.

 

The 117 scorecard is terrible. There were 4 dominant Floyd rounds, 3 for Maidana and the rest were VERY close. 117 implies all close rounds went to Floyd. I don't agree with it.

Edit: the rounds Floyd dominated were more apparent than the ones Maidana dominated... for whatever that is worth.

 

115-113 is ok but 114-114 is not? it's only one swing round away.

 

Clemens and Moretti were too generous to give Rounds 2, 3 and 4 for Mayweather. Smells like Haymon's paycheck.

 

:good

 

The man coming forward should be given the benefit of the doubt in close rounds, WTF is up when the dude laying on the ropes most of the fight is given the benefit? I just don't get it, also Khan is criticized and docked points for holding in his fight yet if it was Ward or even Ali way back, not a word would be spoken. It's so ****ed up, it beggars belief!
Face it, Mayweather would have had to be taken out in a coffin for Maidana to get a draw!

 

We need a breakdown of the scoring from U.S. guys v the scoring from overseas journos.

 

I agree with 116-112 Mayweather or 115-113 Mayweather.

 

117-111 is too wide.
I can agree with the 116-112 card though. I had it 7-5 watching it live. 8-4 on 2nd viewing.

 

I heard the crowd at ringside booing the criminal decision.......................

 

maidana 1,3,4,5,8,11,12

 

116-112 Mayweather

 

:roll: